|

Aliens in the articles of Michail Menshikov

Authors: Tolstenko A.K. Published: 04.07.2014
Published in issue: #3(17)/2014  
DOI: 10.18698/2306-8477-2014-3-192  
Category: The Humanities in Technical University | Chapter: Historical Sciences and Archaeology  
Keywords: M. Menshikov, nationalism, aliens, assimilation, Russian nation, antisemitism

The article deals with the publicism of Michail Menshikov - one of the conservative thinkers of the early twentieth century, known for his criticism of non-titular nationalities of the Russian Empire - "inorodtsi" (aliens). Scientific novelty of the study is in carrying out an analysis of the phenomenon of Menshikov's negative attitude to strangers, including his anti-Semitism, and in examining the problem of motivation for this attitude. The research shows that Menshikov's attitude to aliens was contradictory and ambiguous. Although the most part of his articles was indeed characterized by ethno-national negative rhetoric towards non-titular nationalities, quite rational and sometimes positive assessment of aliens was hidden behind his external aggression. The study is helpful for understanding the causes of everyday and political nationalism, as well as for preventing ethnic conflicts.


References
[1] Menshikov M.O. Vyshe svobody [Higher than freedom]. Moscow, Sovremennyi Pisatel Publ., 1998, 458 p.
[2] Menshikov M.O. Pisma k russkoi natsii [Letters to the Russian nation]. Moscow, 1999, 555 p.
[3] Menshikov M.O. Vechnoe voskresenie [Eternal resurrection]. Moscow, Russkiy vestnik Publ., 2003, 174 p.
[4] Menshikov M.O. Natsionalnaya imperiya [National Imperia]. Moscow, Imper. traditsii, 2004, 505 p.
[5] Menshikov M.O. Kak voskresnet Rossiya? [How to resurrect Russia?]. St. Petersburg, Russkaya simfoniya: Acad. Sci. Library Publ., 2007, 668 p.
[6] Menshikov M.O. Russkoe probuzhdenie [The Russian awakening]. Moscow, Knizhnyi mir, 2007, 415 р.
[7] Sankova S.M. Dva litsa "Novogo vremeni". A.S. Suvorini M.O. Menshikov v zerkaleistoriografii [Two Faces of "New time". A.S. Suvorin, M.O. Menshikov in the mirror of historiography]. Orel, State University-ESPC Publ., 2011, 224 p.
[8] Smolin M.B. Ocherki imperskogo puti. Neizvestnyie russkie conservatory vtoroi poloviny XIX - pervoi polovini XX veka [Essays of the imperial way. Unknown Russian conservatives of mid - and late XIX - early XX century]. Moscow, J. "Moskva", 2000, 301 p.
[9] Sokhriakov Yu.I. Natsionalnaya ideya v otechestvennoi publitsistike XIX - nachala ХХ veka [National idea in domestic journalism XIX - early XX century]. Moscow, Nasledie Publ., 2000, 254 p.
[10] Yudin V.A. Don, 2001, no. 9/12, pp. 196-199.
[11] Kotsyubinsky D.A. Russkiy natsionalizm v nachale XX stoletiya: Rozhdenie i gibel ideologii Vserossiyskogo natsionalnogo soyuza [The Russian nationalism in the early twentieth century: the birth and death of the ideology of the Russian National Union]. Moscow, ROSSPEN Publ., 2001, 525 p.
[12] Repnikov A.V. Konservativnyie kontseptsii pereustroistva Rossii [Conservative concept of rebuilding Russia]. Moscow, Academia Publ., 2007, 519 p.
[13] Sankova S.M. Russkaya partiya v Rossii: obrazovanie i deyatelnost Vserossiyskogo natsionalnogo soyuza (1908-1917) [Russian party in Russia: the formation and activities of Russian National Union (1908-1917)]. Orel, Poligraficheskiy centre Publ., 2006, 369 p.
[14] Shliomin P.I. M.O. Menshikov: mysli o Rossii [M.O. Menshikov: thoughts about Russia]. Moscow, INION Publ., 1997, 208 p.
[15] Zverev N.V. Obshchestvenno-politicheskiie vzgliady M.O. Menshikova (1885-1900). Diss. kand. ist. nauk. [M.O. Menshikov’s socio-political views (1885-1900) PhD Diss.]. Moscow, 2013, 199 p.
[16] Stukalov P.B. Pavel Ivanovich Kovalevsky i Mikhail Osipovich Men’shikov kak ideologi Vserossiyskogo natsional’nogo soyuza. Diss. kand. ist. nauk. [Pavel Ivanovich Kovalevsky and Mikhail Osipovich Menshikov as ideologists of the Russian National Union. Ph.D. Diss.]. Voronezh, 2009, 480 р.
[17] Tolstenko A.K. Liberalnyi i konservativnyi podkhody k etnonatsionalnoi problematike. Sravnitelnyi analiz vzgliadov P.B. Struve i M.O. Menshikova. Diss. kand. ist. nauk. [Liberal and conservative approaches to ethno-national issues. Comparative analysis of P.B. Struve and M.O. Menshikov’s views. Ph.D. Diss.]. Moscow, 2012, 188 p.